Shaw v. Reno
The 1993 case that let voters challenge districts drawn mainly by race
The ruleVoters may challenge under the Equal Protection Clause a redistricting plan that is so irregular on its face that it can be understood only as an effort to separate voters by race, unless the state shows the plan is narrowly tailored to a compelling interest.
Still good law?Yes. Its racial gerrymandering claim remains the law and was central to Louisiana v. Callais (2026). Checked November 12, 2026.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The question
After the 1990 census, North Carolina gained a seat in Congress. The state, about one-fifth Black, had not elected a Black member of Congress since 1901. Under the Voting Rights Act, the Justice Department had to approve its new map, and it objected to a plan with only one majority-Black district. The legislature drew a second.
That district, the 12th, ran about 160 miles through the center of the state, largely following Interstate 85, and for much of its length was no wider than the I-85 corridor. It connected Black neighborhoods in Durham, Greensboro, Winston-Salem and Charlotte.
Five Durham County voters sued, claiming the plan violated the Equal Protection Clause. They did not claim their own votes were diluted. The question was whether a district drawn to separate voters by race could be challenged at all.
The cases before it
| Case | Holding |
|---|---|
| Gomillion v. Lightfoot (1960) | Alabama could not redraw a city's boundaries into a 28-sided shape to exclude almost all Black voters |
| United Jewish Organizations v. Carey (1977) | Upheld New York's use of race in drawing districts to comply with the Voting Rights Act |
| Thornburg v. Gingles (1986) | Set the test for when the Voting Rights Act requires a majority-minority district |
What the Court held
The Court held 5–4 that the voters had stated a valid claim. Justice O'Connor wrote that a plan so irregular that it can be explained only as an effort to separate voters by race must be justified by a compelling government interest and be narrowly tailored to it, like other racial classifications.
She wrote that such a district "bears an uncomfortable resemblance to political apartheid" and risks reinforcing the idea that members of the same race think alike. The Court sent the case back for the lower court to decide whether North Carolina could justify the district.
How the justices divided
| Position | Justices |
|---|---|
| Majority | Rehnquist, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas |
| Dissent | White, Blackmun, Stevens, Souter |
Justice White's dissent argued that the challengers had suffered no injury, since their votes were not diluted, and that drawing districts to help a minority group was very different from excluding it.
What followed
The case returned to the Court as Shaw v. Hunt (1996), which struck down the 12th District. The district was redrawn several times and litigated for more than two decades. The Court later held in Miller v. Johnson (1995) that shape was not the test: what matters is whether race was the predominant factor.
Shaw created a lasting tension that the Court revisited in Louisiana v. Callais (2026): the Voting Rights Act can require race-conscious districts, while the Equal Protection Clause limits them.
How later cases have used it
| Case | How it used this one |
|---|---|
| Miller v. Johnson (1995) | A district need not be bizarrely shaped. The claim succeeds if race was the predominant factor in drawing it. |
| Shaw v. Hunt (1996) | On return to the Court, North Carolina's 12th District was struck down as not narrowly tailored. |
| Easley v. Cromartie (2001) | Upheld a redrawn 12th District, finding that politics rather than race explained its shape. |
| Cooper v. Harris (2017) | Struck down two North Carolina districts, including the 12th, as racial gerrymanders. |
| Louisiana v. Callais (2026) | Struck down Louisiana's second majority-Black district and limited when the Voting Rights Act can justify race-based districts. |
Related entries
- Louisiana v. CallaisThe 2026 case that limited when the Voting Rights Act can justify race-based districts
- Baker v. CarrThe 1962 case that let courts hear challenges to unequal legislative districts
- Bush v. GoreThe 2000 case that ended the Florida recount and settled a presidential election
- PrecedentAn earlier court decision that later courts follow