BriefLaw.us
Lawyers, judges and officials

Sheriff

The chief law enforcement officer of a county, usually elected

In briefA sheriff is the chief law enforcement officer of a county. In nearly every state the office is filled by election, which makes the sheriff answerable to voters and not to a mayor or county board.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What a sheriff does

The duties are set by each state's constitution and statutes. Most sheriffs have three kinds of work.

AreaTypical duties
Law enforcementPatrolling and investigating crime, mainly in parts of the county outside city limits
JailsRunning the county jail, which holds people awaiting trial and those serving short sentences, and transporting prisoners
CourtsProviding courthouse security, serving summonses and subpoenas, carrying out arrest warrants, evictions and court-ordered sales of property

The balance differs widely. In much of the South and West the sheriff is the main police force for the county. In parts of the Northeast the office is largely limited to jails and court work.

The officers who work for a sheriff are called deputies.

Sheriff and police chief

SheriffPolice chief
AreaCountyCity or town
Chosen byVotersMayor, city manager or council
Can be dismissed by superiors?Generally noYes
Runs a jail?UsuallyRarely

Because sheriffs are elected, county officials usually control only their budget.

Where the office exists

There are about 3,000 sheriffs' offices in the United States. Alaska has no counties and no sheriffs, and Connecticut abolished the office in 2000. In Hawaii and Rhode Island, sheriffs are state officers, not county ones. Rhode Island's serve the courts; Hawaii's also guard state buildings and the Honolulu airport. In many states the office is written into the state constitution, so the legislature cannot abolish it.

Most sheriffs serve four-year terms. Qualifications are set by state law and are often modest; some states do not require prior law enforcement experience.

Origin

The word comes from "shire reeve," the king's officer in an English county before the Norman Conquest. The office came to the American colonies in the 1600s. Colonial sheriffs were mostly appointed, though one was elected in Virginia as early as 1652, and after independence the states one by one made the office elective.

Limits on a sheriff's power

A sheriff is bound by the Constitution, by state law and by court orders like any other official.

  • Printz v. United States (1997): in a case brought by two sheriffs, the Supreme Court held that Congress cannot order state and local officers to carry out a federal program, there background checks on gun buyers. Congress therefore cannot force a sheriff to carry out a federal program; whether a sheriff helps is a matter of state law and the sheriff's choice. The ruling gives no power to interfere with federal officers doing their own work.
  • McMillian v. Monroe County (1997): whether a sheriff acts for the state or the county depends on state law. The Court found that Alabama sheriffs act for the state when enforcing the law, so the county could not be sued for a sheriff's conduct.

Some sheriffs have claimed the power to refuse to enforce state or federal laws they consider unconstitutional. Courts have not recognized such a power. A sheriff has discretion over priorities and resources, as other police agencies do, but deciding whether a law is constitutional is a matter for the courts.

Removal

Besides losing an election, a sheriff can be removed in ways that vary by state: recall by voters, impeachment, removal by the governor, or a court proceeding for misconduct.

Related entries