BriefLaw.us
Business, property and technology

Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States

The 1911 case that broke up Standard Oil and created the antitrust "rule of reason"

The ruleThe Sherman Act forbids only unreasonable restraints of trade, judged by a "rule of reason." Standard Oil's combination was an unreasonable restraint and an attempt to monopolize, and it had to be dissolved.

Still good law?Yes. The rule of reason remains the main test for most restraints of trade, alongside rules that treat a few practices, such as price fixing, as illegal in themselves. Checked November 12, 2026.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The question

The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 made illegal "every contract, combination ... or conspiracy, in restraint of trade" and every attempt to monopolize. Read literally, "every" would outlaw ordinary business agreements, since almost any contract restrains trade in some way. The question was what the law actually forbids, and whether the largest company in America had broken it.

The company

John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil grew from an Ohio refinery founded in the 1860s into a combination that, by the 1880s, controlled about 90 percent of American oil refining. It won its position partly through efficiency and partly through secret railroad rebates, price cutting to drive out rivals, and buying competitors. From 1899 its many companies were held by a single holding company, Standard Oil Company of New Jersey.

Ida Tarbell's The History of the Standard Oil Company, published in 1904, turned public opinion against the company. The federal government sued in 1906, and in 1909 a federal court in Missouri ordered the combination dissolved. Standard Oil appealed.

The cases before it

CaseHolding
United States v. E. C. Knight Co. (1895)The Sherman Act did not reach a sugar refining monopoly, because manufacturing was not commerce
Northern Securities Co. v. United States (1904)5–4: a holding company combining two competing railroads violated the act and had to be dissolved

What the Court held

The Court upheld the breakup. Chief Justice White's opinion held that the Sherman Act must be read in light of the common law, and that it bans only restraints of trade that are unreasonable, a standard that became known as the rule of reason.

Applying that standard, the Court found that Standard Oil's history showed an intent to exclude others from the oil trade and to dominate it. Its combination was an unreasonable restraint and an attempt to monopolize. The holding company had to transfer the shares of its subsidiaries back to its own shareholders, within at least six months rather than the 30 days the lower court had allowed.

How the justices divided

All nine justices agreed that Standard Oil had to be broken up. Justice John Marshall Harlan wrote separately to object to the rule of reason. He argued that Congress had written "every" restraint, that the Court had rejected such a reading in earlier cases, and that judges were now rewriting the law.

What followed

Standard Oil was divided into 34 companies. Their successors include ExxonMobil, Chevron and much of what became BP's American business. Because Rockefeller kept shares in all of them, and their stock rose sharply, the breakup made him richer.

Two weeks later the Court applied the same reasoning to break up the American Tobacco Company. In 1914 Congress passed the Clayton Act and created the Federal Trade Commission, partly to give businesses clearer rules than the rule of reason provided.

How later cases have used it

CaseHow it used this one
Chicago Board of Trade v. United States (1918)Justice Brandeis set out how the rule of reason works: a court weighs the business, the restraint, and its history, nature and effect.
United States v. Socony-Vacuum Oil Co. (1940)Price fixing among competitors is illegal in itself, with no inquiry into whether it was reasonable.
Leegin Creative Leather Products v. PSKS (2007)Agreements by which a maker sets minimum resale prices are judged under the rule of reason, overruling a 1911 precedent that had banned them outright.

Related entries

Across the Brief network

People in this entry, on BriefPeople