BriefLaw.us
Civil lawsuits

Subpoena

A legal order to testify or to hand over documents

In briefA subpoena is a written legal order that requires a person to appear and testify, to hand over documents or other evidence, or both. The word is Latin for "under penalty": a person who ignores one can be punished.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Two kinds

KindLatin nameWhat it orders
To testifySubpoena ad testificandumAppear at a trial, hearing or deposition and answer questions under oath
To produceSubpoena duces tecumHand over documents, electronic records or objects, or allow an inspection

A subpoena is aimed at a witness or a holder of records. It differs from a summons, which tells a person they have been sued or charged and must respond, and from a search warrant, which lets officers take evidence themselves.

Who can issue one

  • Courts. In federal civil cases the court clerk issues subpoenas, and a lawyer authorized to practice in that court may issue and sign one. No judge reviews it first.
  • Grand juries, in practice through the prosecutor.
  • Congress and state legislatures, through their committees.
  • Government agencies, where a statute gives them the power.

Limits in federal civil cases

Rule 45 protects the person who receives a subpoena.

  • Distance. A person can generally be made to appear only within 100 miles of where they live, work or regularly do business in person. A party to the case, or a trial witness who would not face substantial expense, can be required to travel anywhere within their own state.
  • Fees. A subpoena to appear must come with a witness fee for one day and mileage.
  • Burden. The party issuing it must avoid imposing undue burden or expense, and a court can penalize one who does not.

Amendments to Rule 45, including new ways to serve a subpoena and a 14-day notice period, are pending and are projected to take effect on December 1, 2027. A revision of Criminal Rule 17, the rule for subpoenas in criminal cases, is on the same track.

How to respond

A person who receives a subpoena has three options: comply, object or ask the court to cancel it.

  • A written objection to a demand for documents is due within 14 days of service, or by the date set for compliance if that is sooner.
  • A motion to quash asks the court to cancel or narrow the subpoena. The court must do so if it allows too little time, exceeds the distance limit, demands privileged material or imposes an undue burden.

Doing nothing is the one wrong answer. A court can hold a person who ignores a subpoena in contempt, which can mean a fine or jail.

A witness who appears can still refuse to answer particular questions on grounds such as the privilege against self-incrimination or attorney-client privilege.

Subpoenas to presidents and from Congress

  • United States v. Nixon (1974): a president must obey a subpoena for evidence in a criminal trial; a general claim of executive privilege does not defeat it.
  • Trump v. Vance (2020): a sitting president has no absolute immunity from a state grand jury's subpoena for his private records.
  • Trump v. Mazars (2020): when Congress subpoenas a president's records, courts must weigh whether it really needs them for a valid legislative purpose and whether the subpoena is no broader than reasonably necessary.

Refusing a congressional subpoena can be prosecuted as contempt of Congress, a misdemeanor carrying one to twelve months in jail and a fine.

Related entries