BriefLaw.us
Legal Latin and phrases

Sui generis

Of its own kind; unlike anything else and needing its own rules

In briefSui generis is Latin for "of its own kind." A lawyer or judge uses it to say that something does not fit any existing category and has to be treated by rules of its own.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

How the phrase is used

Law works by sorting things into categories, such as contract or tort, property or service, state or private actor, and then applying the rules for that category. Sometimes a thing will not sort. Calling it sui generis is a way of saying two things at once: the usual rules do not apply automatically, and whatever is decided about it should not be carried over to other cases without care.

It is a description, not a test. It does not by itself say what rules apply.

Examples

AreaWhat courts and lawmakers treat as one of a kindWhy
The ConstitutionThe District of ColumbiaIt is the seat of government and not a state, so it has some of the rights of a state and not others
Native American tribesThe relationship between tribes and the United StatesTribes are neither foreign nations nor states, and the law that governs them has developed its own rules
PropertyRights in a body, a grave or genetic materialThey resemble property in some ways but not in others
Corporate lawSome public corporations and agencies created by CongressThey are part government, part private company
Intellectual propertySpecial statutes for particular creationsSee below

Sui generis protection for creations

When Congress decides that a kind of creation needs protection but fits poorly under patent or copyright, it sometimes writes a separate law just for it. These are often called sui generis regimes.

  • Boat hull and deck designs are protected for ten years under a 1998 statute.
  • Computer chip layouts, called mask works, are protected for ten years under a 1984 statute.
  • Plant varieties, whether grown from seed, from tubers or by cuttings and grafts, are protected under the Plant Variety Protection Act of 1970, which was expanded in 2018.

The European Union has gone further, with a sui generis right in databases, lasting 15 years, that the United States has not adopted. In the United States a mere collection of facts is protected only if its selection or arrangement is original (Feist Publications v. Rural Telephone Service, 1991).

In court opinions

Judges use the phrase most often to limit a ruling. By calling a situation sui generis, a court signals that it is deciding this case alone and not setting a rule for others. The Supreme Court has called the District of Columbia "truly sui generis in our governmental structure" (District of Columbia v. Carter, 1973), and has described the presidency and the military in similar terms, as unique or separate.

In zoning

British planning law lists some uses, such as theaters and petrol stations, that belong to no use class. Planners call them "sui generis," and a change to or from one generally needs planning permission. The usage is mainly British.

Related phrases

  • Ejusdem generis, "of the same kind," is a rule for reading lists. General words at the end of a list, such as "and other vehicles," are read to cover only things like those named before them.
  • Genus and species are sometimes used for a broad category and a narrower one within it.

Related entries