BriefLaw.us
Criminal cases

Suspended sentence

A sentence the court imposes but does not carry out, on conditions

In briefA suspended sentence is a criminal sentence that a judge imposes but does not carry out, as long as the offender meets conditions for a set period. If the conditions are met, the sentence is never served. If they are broken, the court can order it carried out.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Two forms

Courts suspend sentences in two ways, and the difference matters if the offender later violates.

FormWhat the judge doesOn a violation
Suspended executionSets a specific sentence, such as two years in jail, and suspends itThe judge can order that sentence served
Suspended impositionDelays deciding the sentence at allThe judge can impose any sentence the law allowed for the original crime

Some sentences are partly suspended: for example, a year in jail with all but 30 days suspended.

Conditions

The suspension usually comes with a period of probation. Typical conditions are:

  • committing no new crime
  • reporting to a probation officer
  • staying in the area
  • keeping a job or attending school
  • paying fines and restitution
  • treatment for drugs, alcohol or mental health
  • staying away from the victim

Is it a conviction?

Usually. A suspended sentence follows a finding or plea of guilt, and in most cases the conviction stands. It can count as a prior offense and carry the same consequences as other convictions. Its effect on firearm rights depends on whether state law treats the outcome as a conviction.

Some states allow a different arrangement, often called deferred adjudication or a suspended imposition of sentence, under which no conviction is entered if the person completes probation. For federal immigration law, though, a deferred adjudication after a guilty plea usually still counts as a conviction, and a suspended prison term counts at its full length.

Suspended sentences, probation and parole

  • Probation is the supervision that usually goes with a suspended sentence. The terms are often used together.
  • Parole is early release from a prison sentence that has partly been served. A suspended sentence avoids prison from the start.

Violations

A judge cannot simply carry out a suspended sentence on suspicion. In Gagnon v. Scarpelli (1973), the Supreme Court held that a probationer facing revocation is entitled, as a parolee is, to a preliminary hearing and a final hearing, with written notice of the claimed violation and a chance to be heard. Whether a lawyer must be provided is decided case by case.

A suspended jail sentence also triggers the right to a lawyer. In Alabama v. Shelton (2002), the Court held that a state may not impose a suspended jail sentence on a defendant who could not afford a lawyer, was not given one and did not waive one, because the sentence could later lead to actual imprisonment.

Federal courts

Federal judges once suspended sentences under their general power, until the Supreme Court held in 1916 (Ex parte United States, often called the Killits case) that they had no power to suspend a sentence indefinitely unless Congress authorized it. Congress passed the federal Probation Act in 1925. Under the Sentencing Reform Act of 1984, federal courts no longer suspend sentences; for crimes committed after November 1, 1987, probation is a sentence in its own right.

Around the world

Many countries use the same idea, such as a suspended sentence with probation in Canada or a suspended sentence order in England and Wales.

Related entries