BriefLaw.us
Torts and injuries

Tort

A civil wrong that lets the injured person sue for damages

In briefA tort is a wrongful act that injures someone and gives that person the right to sue for compensation. It covers harms that do not come from breaking a contract: a car crash, a defective product, a punch, a false statement that ruins a reputation.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The three types

TypeWhat makes the defendant liableExamples
Intentional tortsThe defendant meant to do the actBattery, assault, false imprisonment, trespass, fraud
NegligenceThe defendant failed to take reasonable careMost car accidents, medical malpractice, a slip on an unmarked wet floor
Strict liabilityThe activity itself, with no need to prove faultDefective products, blasting with explosives, keeping dangerous animals

Most tort cases are negligence cases.

What a negligence claim requires

A plaintiff must prove four things:

  1. Duty. The defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of reasonable care.
  2. Breach. The defendant did not meet that duty.
  3. Causation. The breach caused the harm.
  4. Damages. The plaintiff suffered an actual loss.

In most states the plaintiff's own carelessness reduces what he can recover, in proportion to his share of the blame. Many of those states bar recovery altogether once the plaintiff is half or more at fault, and a few bar it for any fault at all.

Tort and crime

The same act can be both. A person who hits someone can be prosecuted for assault and sued for battery. The two cases are separate.

TortCrime
Who brings the caseThe injured personThe government
PurposeTo compensate the victimTo punish the wrongdoer
Standard of proofMore likely than notBeyond a reasonable doubt
ResultMoney damagesFine, probation or prison

An acquittal in the criminal case does not block the civil suit, because the standards of proof differ.

Damages

  • Compensatory damages make up for the loss: medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering.
  • Punitive damages punish especially bad conduct. The Supreme Court has held that the Constitution limits them. In State Farm v. Campbell (2003) it said that few awards more than nine times the compensatory damages will be upheld, while declining to set a fixed limit.

Where tort law comes from

Tort law is mostly common law, made by state courts one case at a time, and it differs from state to state. Legislatures have added statutes on specific points, such as caps on some damages.

The federal government can be sued in tort only because it has agreed to be. The Federal Tort Claims Act of 1946 allows suits for the negligence of federal employees, with exceptions.

The word

"Tort" comes from the Latin for "twisted," by way of French. It has no connection to the pastry.

Related entries