BriefLaw.us
Criminal cases

Trial in absentia

A criminal trial held without the defendant present

In briefA trial in absentia, Latin for "in absence," is a criminal trial that goes ahead without the defendant in the courtroom. American law allows it only in narrow situations, because a defendant has a constitutional right to be present.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The right to be present

The Sixth Amendment gives a defendant the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against him," and the Due Process Clause protects the right to be present at every stage where presence matters to a fair hearing. In federal court, unless the rules provide otherwise, Rule 43 requires the defendant to be present at the initial appearance, the arraignment, the plea, every stage of trial including jury selection and the verdict, and sentencing.

When a trial may go on without the defendant

The right can be lost by the defendant's own conduct.

SituationRule
The defendant leaves after the trial has begunThe trial may continue (Taylor v. United States, 1973; Rule 43(c))
The defendant disrupts the trial after a warningThe judge may remove them (Illinois v. Allen, 1970)
The defendant flees before trialA federal trial may not begin (Crosby v. United States, 1993)
An offense punishable by up to a yearWith the defendant's written consent, the court may let the case proceed without them, or by video
An organization, such as a corporationMay appear through a lawyer who is present

In Taylor, the defendant attended the morning of the first day of his trial and did not return. The Supreme Court held that he had waived his right to be there. In Illinois v. Allen, the defendant repeatedly threatened the judge and refused to stop. The Court held that a judge facing such conduct may bind and gag the defendant, hold them in contempt, or remove them from the courtroom while the trial continues.

The Crosby rule

Crosby was released on bail and disappeared before his federal trial began. The trial went ahead without him, and he was convicted. The Supreme Court unanimously reversed. Rule 43, it held, allows a trial to continue when a defendant who was present at the start later leaves, but it does not allow a trial to begin when the defendant is absent from the start. The line is practical: once a trial has begun, the defendant knows it is under way and has chosen to leave.

Crosby interpreted the federal rule, not the Constitution. States set their own rules, and some allow a trial to begin when a defendant who knew the date chose not to come.

Safeguards

When a trial continues in the defendant's absence, the defendant keeps the right to a lawyer, and the lawyer continues the defense. Judges may tell the jury not to hold the absence against the defendant. A defendant who returns can usually rejoin the trial.

A defendant who flees can also be charged separately with failing to appear.

Other countries

Practice varies widely. Some European countries allow full trials in absentia, often with a right to a new trial if the defendant is later found. The European Court of Human Rights has held that such a conviction is fair only if the defendant knowingly gave up the right to attend, tried to escape trial, or can obtain a fresh hearing (Sejdovic v. Italy, 2006).

International criminal courts generally require the accused to be present at trial. The main exceptions were the Nuremberg tribunal after the Second World War and the Special Tribunal for Lebanon, which closed in 2023. The International Criminal Court can confirm charges against an absent suspect but cannot try one.

Related entries