BriefLaw.us
Trials, juries and evidence

Voir dire

The questioning of prospective jurors to choose a fair jury

In briefVoir dire is the stage of a trial in which prospective jurors are questioned to decide who will serve. The phrase comes from Law French, the language of English courts after the Norman Conquest, and is usually translated "to speak the truth." Its purpose is to find jurors who can decide the case fairly on the evidence.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

How it works

A group of citizens, called the venire or jury panel, is summoned from voter, driver's license or similar lists. The judge, the lawyers or both then ask them questions about their background, experiences and views that might affect how they see the case. Do they know anyone involved? Have they been the victim of a similar crime? Have they formed an opinion from news coverage?

Federal judges often conduct most of the questioning themselves, though the rules let them allow the lawyers to question jurors. In many state courts the lawyers do much of the questioning themselves.

Removing jurors

Each side can ask the court to excuse a prospective juror in two ways.

ChallengeGroundsNumber
For causeA specific reason the person cannot be impartial, such as a relationship with a party or a fixed opinion about guiltUnlimited; the judge decides
PeremptoryNo reason need be givenLimited by statute or rule

In federal court the numbers of peremptory challenges are:

CaseGovernment or plaintiffDefendant or defendants
Capital case2020
Felony610
Misdemeanor33
Civil case33

Co-defendants share their challenges unless the judge allows more. State numbers vary.

Limits on peremptory challenges

A peremptory challenge needs no reason, but it may not be used for a forbidden one.

  • Batson v. Kentucky (1986): a prosecutor may not strike jurors because of their race.
  • J.E.B. v. Alabama ex rel. T.B. (1994): or because of their sex.
  • The rule applies to defense lawyers and to parties in civil cases too.

When one side objects, the court follows three steps. The objecting party must show facts suggesting discrimination. The other side must then give a neutral reason. The judge decides whether that reason is genuine or a pretext.

In Flowers v. Mississippi (2019), the same lead prosecutor had tried the defendant six times. Across the six trials the State struck 41 of the 42 Black prospective jurors it could have struck. The Supreme Court held that the strike of one Black juror at the sixth trial was motivated in substantial part by discriminatory intent, and reversed the conviction.

Some states have gone further. Arizona abolished peremptory challenges in all jury trials from January 2022. Washington (2018) and California (2022) have adopted rules that make it easier to challenge a strike that may reflect bias; since 2026 California's rule applies in criminal cases and only certain civil ones.

Death penalty cases

In a capital case, jurors may be excused if their views on the death penalty would prevent or substantially impair them from following the law (Wainwright v. Witt, 1985). A juror may not be excused merely for having doubts about it.

Other meanings

The term is also used for a hearing outside the jury's presence to test whether a witness is qualified, such as an expert, or whether evidence is admissible. In English and some other legal systems it also refers to this preliminary examination of a witness.

Related entries