BriefLaw.us
Speech, press and religion

Wisconsin v. Yoder

The 1972 case that exempted Amish children from high school attendance laws

The ruleA state's interest in compulsory education does not outweigh the free exercise rights of Amish parents who keep their children out of school after eighth grade for religious reasons.

Still good law?Yes. Employment Division v. Smith (1990) recast it as a "hybrid" case, but Mahmoud v. Taylor (2025) revived it, holding that laws that substantially interfere with parents' religious upbringing of their children face strict scrutiny even if neutral and generally applicable. Checked November 12, 2026.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The question

Wisconsin required children to attend school until age 16. Jonas Yoder and Wallace Miller, members of the Old Order Amish, and Adin Yutzy, of the Conservative Amish Mennonite Church, lived near New Glarus, Wisconsin. They sent their children to school through eighth grade but not to high school.

The Amish believe that salvation requires life in a church community separate from the world. High school, the parents said, would expose their teenagers to worldly values and take them away from the community during the years when they learn the farming and household skills of Amish life. The parents were convicted and fined $5 each.

The question was whether the First Amendment's Free Exercise Clause required Wisconsin to exempt them.

The cases before it

CaseHolding
Meyer v. Nebraska (1923)A state could not ban teaching in foreign languages, protecting parents' rights over their children's education
Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925)A state could not require all children to attend public rather than private schools
Sherbert v. Verner (1963)A state must have a compelling interest to deny benefits to a worker who would not work on her Sabbath

What the Court held

The Court ruled for the parents. Chief Justice Burger's opinion found that the Amish way of life was rooted in sincere religious belief, not merely personal preference, and that compulsory high school threatened its survival.

Weighing that burden against the state's interest, the Court found the state's interest in one or two more years of formal schooling was not strong enough. The Amish provided their own vocational training, produced self-sufficient, law-abiding citizens, and had done so for some 300 years. The Court stressed that its ruling was narrow and that few other groups could make the same showing.

How the justices divided

PositionJustices
MajorityBurger, Brennan, Stewart, White, Marshall, Blackmun
Dissent in partDouglas
Not participatingPowell, Rehnquist

Justice Douglas agreed as to Jonas Yoder, whose daughter had testified that her beliefs matched her parents'. He dissented as to the other parents, arguing that the children's own wishes had not been heard, and that a child who wanted to become "a pianist or an astronaut or an oceanographer" might be denied the chance.

What followed

Yoder is a leading case on both religious freedom and parents' rights. In Employment Division v. Smith (1990), the Court held that neutral laws generally need not exempt religious practice, and explained Yoder as a "hybrid" case because it also involved parents' rights. Congress responded to Smith with the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993.

In Mahmoud v. Taylor (2025), the Court, 6–3 in an opinion by Justice Alito, relied heavily on Yoder to hold that parents were entitled to a preliminary injunction letting them opt their children out of lessons that substantially interfered with their children's religious upbringing, and that such burdens call for strict scrutiny even under neutral, generally applicable policies. In 2026 the Court applied both cases on its emergency docket to hold that parents were likely entitled to be told of a child's gender transition at school.

How later cases have used it

CaseHow it used this one
Employment Division v. Smith (1990)Held that neutral, generally applicable laws need not exempt religious practice, and explained Yoder as a "hybrid" case also involving parents' rights.
Mahmoud v. Taylor (2025)Relied on Yoder to hold that parents may opt their children out of public school lessons using LGBTQ-themed storybooks that burden the parents' religious upbringing of them.
Mirabelli v. Bonta (2026)On the emergency docket, applied Mahmoud and Yoder to hold that parents were likely entitled to be told of a child's gender transition at school.

Related entries